Showing posts with label Martin Luther. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Martin Luther. Show all posts

Apr 16, 2015

Did Jesus descend to Hades? Part 1


I have written previously on whether or not Jesus descended into hell here. But my friend, Andrew, tagged me in a comment for this article by Joe Rigney on Jesus descending to Hades wondering what my thoughts were . I couldn't comment on the Facebook post because it was shared by someone with restricted comments so I thought I'd share them with everyone. Here's the link to the article followed by quotes and my commentary.

"We all know that Jesus died... But what happened after he died? We know that his body was laid in Joseph’s tomb, but what about his human soul?"
And what I find shocking is that Rigney conclude that..."Jesus’ soul went to Hades...." The reason why I find this shocking is because Joe Rigney blogs at desiringgod.org which is a staunchly reformed website named after the book, "Desiring God" by their chief figurehead, John Piper. Piper has spoken about and written his own blog post on this subject defending that the textual evidence for such a view is weak and he believes Jesus' soul went to Heaven when he died until his resurrection.

Asking what happened after Jesus died is a great question. I think that the article by Rigney does an excellent job of addressing it and gives a thoroughgoing explanation with an encouraging message at the end.  In my post on whether Jesus descended into hell, I make a similar claim: "...[Jesus] was among the dead between his death and resurrection whether you take it as a literal grave of the dead or a metaphorical/spiritual underworld/realm." So, I'm in support of this article's conclusions as one of two options. However, I have not come to the same understanding as this author does. 
"Death is separation, a dividing of things that ought to be united. Fundamentally, it is separation from God....But of course, death is more than just separation from God. Death also marks the separation of the soul from the body. God made human beings to be embodied souls and ensouled bodies, and death rips this union asunder."
 First, I don't agree with his definition of death. This isn't how we define the term or use it in most instances, and the Bible doesn't generally use it this way either. With rare exceptions where the word is used figuratively, 'death' means that the person dies physically. If one is a dualist, which I am not, and one thinks that the soul departs from the body at death this departure is still not death. This would be an effect of the death of the body. It is the body that is said to be dead and the spirit/soul is 'alive' and therefore not dead. Therefore death cannot mean separation in this instance, but the death of the body causes separation of body and soul.

Second, I don't think the soul/spirit is some immaterial substance that can survive death. With Martin Luther and many others I hold to 'soul sleep' and think that the human person is a whole that cannot be separated and survive. I am what in theological terms is called a 'monist'; I believe a human person is a single entity. Yes, it can be described as having various 'parts', but they make up one indivisible whole. In philosophy of mind this view is referred to as 'non-reductive physicalism'.

So I don't think of a human being as having a soul. I think you are a soul primarily because it is what I see in the Bible. In Genesis, for example, it says that God made man out of the dust and breathed the breath of life into him and he became a living soul. A 'soul' was not breathed into him, life was and the 'living dust' is called a living soul. Not only that, but after the fall, God says 'for dust you are and to dust you shall return.'. And the word for 'soul' is used for all of the other animals created beforehand. This is why the more modern translations say 'creature' instead of soul in this instance. They are being more consistent than the KJV and other translations where the creation of man is the first use of the english word 'soul' making it appear as a more unique creation than the text suggests in that manner (Though I do think the text is saying humans are unique by other means).

Now, I don't hold this monist view dogmatically and could very well be wrong. The point is that words we often think imply dualism are not doing so necessarily. I agree with Dr. Glenn Peoples who thinks that the primary reason for upholding a dualist view of human persons is cultural and theological (Read more about his defence of monism here and here).  And what is the primary/only theological belief that requires dualism? The belief that when people die they are in Hades and Paradise or Hell and Heaven....or in the case of Rigney, Hades and Heaven!

More to come in part 2...

Mar 19, 2014

MacArthur ponders whether visits to heaven are for real


I am not a fan of John MacArthur or Answers in Genesis, but I came across this article when a Facebook friend shared it this week and found points of agreement and disagreement that I think are valuable to point out. This is how MacArthur opens the discussion:
In recent years, Christian booksellers have inundated the evangelical world with testimonies from people who say they visited heaven in near-death experiences. Their stories are full of specific details about what heaven is like, who is there, and what is happening in the celestial realm. But when we compare their claims with Scripture, it becomes clear that they are merely figments of the human imagination, not true visions of heaven as it is described in God’s Word.
And why is that? He goes on to say that if you had a true vision of heaven...
You would be preoccupied instead with the majesty and grace of the One whose glory fills the place. Sadly, undiscerning readers abound, and they take these postmodern accounts of heaven altogether seriously. The stratospheric sales figures and far-reaching influence of these books ought to be a matter of serious concern for anyone who truly loves the Word of God.
I agree with his basic point despite his blaming of postmodernism (and other red herrings ad nauseum). What are we to make of these experiences people have when they nearly die (or medically speaking when they do die)? I think that on biblical grounds we can largely dismiss these accounts as not actually referring to the place Christians call heaven, which is where God can be fully beheld in glorious light causing those experiencing these visions to fall down in awe. These near death experiences (NDEs) are highly subjective and often sound more like a temporary and partial loss of vision (a tunnel with a light at the end), experiences similar to a dream, and encounters with known persons or objects. I am personally unconvinced that any NDE reveals details about heaven.

MacArthur goes on to discuss what the Bible says about heaven and ends with this little nugget: "Not one biblical person ever gave any recorded account of his or her postmortem experience in the realm of departed souls." First, I completely agree that the Bible never mentions anything of these sorts of experiences. But second, why do we think anyone goes to heaven when they die based on this truth claim? If the Bible never mentions anyone having any experience of heaven after death then why should we think that anyone goes to heaven when they die in the first place? I think MacArthur is spinning his wheels at this point.

Until recently I also held that people go to heaven when they die, but I now strongly doubt and tentatively reject that concept altogether. The full explanation is long, but the first thing that lead me to make this radical change was that the Bible is even more silent on the subject than I've already asserted above. The fact is that the Bible never once says that anyone goes to heaven when they die. Let me say that again. There is no explicit claim that anyone goes to heaven at the moment of death. I'm sure this fact and my admission comes as a shock to some readers, but I'll do another series of blog posts on this subject at some point soon to break up the series on Creation. The short version is that, along with William Tyndale and Martin Luther, I tentatively hold the minority position of Christian Mortalism, which holds that when people die they are in 'soul sleep' until the resurrection.

Like MacArthur, I do believe in heaven and that the Bible speaks of it as a spiritual reality and the place where God dwells. However, when he wraps up his entry speaking about the glories of heaven, what he really means is that we are to look forward to dying and being in heaven forever, and that the earth is a bad place to be avoided. He says that our citizenship is in heaven, we are strangers on earth, and that the heavenly Jerusalem city is the capital of heaven where we will live forever. The problem I have with this is, it seems to be purely non-physical,  rejects creation, and seems to ignore key pointers as to the direction of what goes where in the final state of all things. For example, we await Jesus from heaven, the heavenly Jerusalem will come down from heaven to the earth, and that paradise (which I think is clearly the new creation) is also fiercely physical and earthly, and in some sense congruent with present experience. I think MacArthur pushes too hard in his rhetoric, clings to a gnostic leaning tradition of escaping earth to a harp-filled golden city on a cloud, and ultimately misses the full redemption of all things in creation. Along with many theologians, I think that the final state involves some sort of merging of heaven and earth into a transformed reality that involves a renewed, physical creation.

Some people refer to a physical place, even a physical earth, when they use the word 'heaven' to denote the final state. If we use the word in this way, then in the end perhaps the NDEs are more like the real 'heaven' than MacArthur is ready to admit.